• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to James Angelo's Underground Pizza

At James Angelo's Underground Pizza, we celebrate our passion for craft pizza that brings communities together. Nestled in the heart of Kamuela, Hawaii, our pizzeria blends traditional methods with innovative toppings, offering an array of vegan and vegetarian options to cater to diverse palates. We pride ourselves on a casual, family-friendly atmosphere, complete with waitstaff service and convenient features like free Wi-Fi and private parking. Whether you're here for lunch, dinner, or a special celebration, our commitment to quality ingredients and heartfelt flavor shines through in every slice. Join us for the perfect pizza experience!

James Angelo's Underground Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

Jeffrey Jaxon T.
Jeffrey Jaxon T.

im from oahu visiting big island this pizza place is the best best pizza i ever had. everything is good. i will surely comeback

Joe L.
Joe L.

Favorite stop on our way back from Hilo. Great pizza, fresh toppings. It's small inside and there are tables on the lanai but it's Waimea so the wind is usually howling and it's cold!.

Tim W.
Tim W.

Thin flavorful veggie pizza with just enough of everything would have been perfect but added an eggplant Parmesan sandwich and things got crazy. Highly recommend this old school pizza place when you have an hankering for Italian fare.

Leah H.
Leah H.

For our Galentines dinner we were craving pizza, happened to find this place, super glad , that happened. Small local pizza joint that had an east coast pizza vibe. Flour on the floor, flour in the air. Pizza made in front of your eyes. Fresh ingredients, huge pizza, I wish treat the menu all way I may have order by the slice but we love the pizza anyways. Orders the spinach and garlic white, we added the bacon, chicken and artichoke hearts. Love the big mugs to put our root beer in!! Service was many serve your self, but they will bring our your pizza. Only down side to this place I feel was the olive was a little heavy and make sure you have CASH!!!! That's all they take!!!!

Jennifer C.
Jennifer C.

Omgosh! Yum! We got the spinach and garlic white pizza + bacon, grilled chicken and artichoke hearts! The olive oil was a little heavy, but it didn't take away from the flavor. Just a little messy. We dined in - there's four tables and an outside picnic table. Low lighting, family friendly and real authentic pizza place vibes. Did I teleport to the East Coast by chance? Everyone was nice, friendly and attentive -- for being Valentine's Day and a Friday night! If you're in the area and wanting pizza, I say, stop here! 4.3/5! Bring cash and your appetite! This pizza is filling!!

Jenny W.
Jenny W.

The food here is always so good! Cash only. Call in your order before hand and eat there it's the best. There's a gas station around the corner and you can buy drinks!

Dave R.
Dave R.

Another amazing pizza again tonight! You gotta check it out! Always love the traditional NU style!

Mandana B.
Mandana B.

Pizza was delicious! We ordered a pizza to go on our way back to our hotel and the pizza was ready within 20 minutes. It was super tasty and very fresh. You can tell the ingredients are high quality. I wish we had a chance to visit again during out trip. Will be back in the future. - Cash only - Good service - Quick - Fresh

Michelle D.
Michelle D.

Went back after a few years and it was stellar. Maybe because James was working, I'm not sure, but it was fabulous. The garlic knots were the best I have ever had and the pizza by the slice was made fresh and couldn't have tasted better -- also came as a double slice so it's a ton of food at a great value. Super fresh toppings and a great crust and sauce. Definitely going back next time. It was also nice to be able to eat inside and outside when a little rain storm came through. Cozy vibe. I wanted to give 4 stars because he's cash only - but there is an ATM next door and the food was so good I have to stay with 5 stars.

Location

Welcome to the savory world of James Angelo's Underground Pizza, nestled in the scenic beauty of Kamuela, Hawaii. This vibrant pizzeria offers a delightful culinary escape that caters to all, making it a must-visit spot for pizza lovers and families alike.

At James Angelo's, the passion for pizza shines through in every slice. Whether you're a meat lover, a vegetarian, or even vegan, the extensive menu presents a variety of options that cater to diverse dietary needs. It's not just about the toppings; it's about crafting an experience that brings people together over delicious food.

  • Reservations and Accessibility: Planning a special gathering? You can easily make reservations to ensure a seamless dining experience.
  • Catering Options: Perfect for parties or events, their catering services make entertaining a breeze.
  • Family-Friendly Atmosphere: With a casual vibe, TV entertainment, and a gender-neutral restroom, everyone feels welcome, making it ideal for children and groups.
  • Payment Convenience: Accepting Apple Pay, Android Pay, and credit cards enhances the modern dining experience so you can focus more on enjoying your meal.
  • Parking & Accessibility: Convenient private lot parking ensures easy access, whether you arrive by car or bike.

The dishes served are not only flavorful but crafted with care and creativity. Every bite tells a story, whether you're indulging in a classic or trying one of their unique signatures. The combination of fresh ingredients and artisanal techniques results in pizzas that are heartwarming and satisfying.

So, if you are in the mood for lunch or dinner, don’t miss the opportunity to explore the delectable offerings at James Angelo's Underground Pizza. Call them at (808) 885-7888 or visit their cozy spot at 64-974 Mamalahoa Hwy Kamuela, HI 96743. With free Wi-Fi and a moderate noise level, it's easy to relax and enjoy a meal with friends or family. Come taste why this pizzeria stands out in the heart of Hawaii!